Magazine
Young People Are Losing Interest in Learning – and It's Not Just About Phones

Technology

Young People Are Losing Interest in Learning – and It's Not Just About Phones

Why teenagers are losing motivation to learn, how school curricula, assessment and lack of autonomy affect this – and why banning smartphones does not solve the problem.

· 3 min read

Translated with AI. Original: Українська

Banning smartphones will not automatically make lessons interesting. The debate about school education increasingly boils down to screens, social media and teenagers' supposed inability to concentrate. Yet researcher and author Jenny Anderson points to a deeper problem: students may lose interest not only because of digital distractions, but because of the way learning itself is organized. When a schoolchild does not understand why they need certain knowledge, has almost no influence over the process and constantly expects to be assessed, motivation weakens regardless of where the phone is.

One key factor is lack of autonomy. At school, students usually do not choose what to study, at what pace to work or how to demonstrate their results. The curriculum, timetable, homework and tests are set in advance. Structure is necessary for learning, but when it leaves no room for personal decisions, a teenager gets used to following instructions instead of taking initiative. Learning turns into a sequence of tasks to be handed in, rather than a process one wants to understand.

The second problem is the gap between school knowledge and real life. Students may memorize formulas, dates and rules without seeing where they will be useful outside the classroom. When material is presented without context, it is hard to grasp its value. By contrast, tasks linked to real situations, research or practical projects make it possible to see the results of one's own work. This does not mean every lesson has to be entertainment. The point is a clear answer to the question: why am I learning this?

Assessment systems also affect motivation. If the main goal becomes the grade, a student starts focusing on whatever will help them get it: the right answer, the teacher's requirements, the test criteria. In such a system, a mistake is perceived as a threat to the grade rather than as part of learning. This can reduce willingness to ask questions, try more difficult tasks and admit that one does not know something. Instead of curiosity, a strategy of minimal risk emerges – doing just enough to get the required result.

Smartphones do matter in this situation. Notifications, short videos and constantly changing content create an easily accessible source of rapid stimulation. Against this backdrop, a lesson that demands sustained effort and offers no instant reward may seem especially slow. But a phone can intensify the problem without necessarily being its root cause. If a student sees no meaning in a task, banning the device alone will not create that meaning.

Restoring engagement requires changes in the learning experience itself: more research-based tasks, opportunities to make choices, discuss ideas and apply knowledge in practice. Relationships with the teacher are also important – whether it is safe to make mistakes in class, and whether one can disagree and ask questions. Autonomy does not mean the absence of rules, just as interesting learning does not mean constant entertainment. It is about balance between demands, support and the opportunity to influence one's own process.

There is no universal solution for all schools: engagement is influenced by age, academic workload, family circumstances, teacher training and the resources of an institution. However, focusing only on smartphones risks overlooking the reasons why students disengage from learning. It is not enough for teenagers to remove the source of distraction – they need a reason to bring their attention back. That reason emerges when learning gives not just a grade, but a sense of meaning, competence and personal influence.

Also read: EU Wants to Change the Rules of Childhood Online: Age Restrictions May Extend to Social Media, YouTube, Games and AI Chatbots

Text: Arina Blyzniuk

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.

Your comment appears after the editors review it. No links or phone numbers. No email needed.

Discuss on Telegram

Read also